Chicago America's Most Stressful City?

According to the latest basically meaningless yet weirdly post-worthy list from Forbes Magazine, Chicago is the most stressful city in America. The rankings used housings costs, cost of living, a city's air quality, the number of sunny days per year, and population density. So wait: Expensive, crowded, stinky, grey cities breed stress? Blink blink. Sayeth Forbes: "Chicago has a 7.3% unemployment rate, the eighth most polluted air in our ranking and in city where everybody drives to get around, a gallon of gas costs a nickel under $4 dollars." (Everyone here drives to get around?) We also had the second-highest population density. Hear that, person who lives so hilariously close to me they can see my computer screen from their house? The other stressful cities are, from most to least, New York, Detroit, LA, San Francisco, San Diego, Cleveland, Sal Lake City, Providence and Philadelphia. [Forbes]

Comments (36) [rss]

Aside from any of the other points of BS methodology, it's just plain ridiculous that any city in the country could come second to New York City in any sort of "stress index." Come on now.

I dunno. I think I agree. I slowly am beginning to hate everyone. I have lived in this city my entire life. Its getting a little bit hectic. Also, YES, everyone drives unnecessarily drives in the damn city. If more people did not, we might possibly have a better transportation system.

I'd be stressed if I drove unnecessarily drove too.

I have lived here for a few years now. I've lived in 7 different cities, 5 different states.

Hands down Chicago is the most stressful place I've ever lived in.

I think that I would rate it higher than NYC because in NYC it's easier to 'escape' the city. Even when you're IN the city, there is, at the very least, Central Park. Central Park is HUGE. You can go bird watching in Central Park and probably fill up your birdwatching notebook...there are hundreds of bird species living in Central Park! And other wildlife too.

And in all of the other cities I've lived in, it's only a quick drive to being 'out of the city' and into glorious countryside...mountains and vistas.

Not so in Chicago. Chicago is also the 'clique-iest' city I've ever lived in. That alone, to me, is very stressful.

These are just my personal experiences and opinions, not meant to get any Chicago-lovers' jockies in a twist.

STRESS?! WHAT FUCKING STRESS?! SF:KLJfpqoiwef;jklasdf;kljasfkvx;ksjdlf!!!!

user-pic

I just wish they would leave Detroit off lists like this. It's like taking the skinny, cross-eyed underdeveloped kid and pointing out that he sucks at football. Then, pointing out, he's probably also going to suck at basketball. Then later telling him he is terrible at baseball. Then acting surprised when he is also worst at tennis.

WE GET IT. DETROIT IS A MESS. WE ARE LAST IN NEARLY EVERY POSSIBLE CATEGORY. LEAVE US ALONE. COMPARING US TO ANY CITY IN ANY OBJECTIVE WAY, WE WILL COME IN LAST. UNDERSTOOD.

Chicago is the MOST stress-inducing place I have ever lived too.

There's a lot of talk about how friendly Chicagoan people are compared with other metropolitan dwellers - which is mostly true - but don't expect any of them to be able to give directions anywhere. I'm serious about this. If you need directions, go out of your way to ask somebody with a detectable non-Chicago accent.

Another stressful thing about city natives is their surprisingly provincial take on the world. Don't make the mistake of taking offense at a Chicagoan for not showing a lot of interest in where you're from, even after you've done them the favor of listening to their umpteenth story about their youth at St. Barnabas in Beverly.

And like Ingrid said - sure the downtown architecture is unique, but on an average day there's no escaping the blocks and blocks of faded brown brick. On the rare occasion when I discover a new place in the city, I have to be ready for a let down because there's always a potential that it will be too dangerous, or too expensive to really enjoy, or on a bus-line that quits running at 11 pm, or in an area where I'm not the right color ... it's always something.

I've done seven years in this city, but I've never had to go about my daily business in a car. Is it the price of gas keeping me off the road? Hell no - I have an efficient Honda. It's the god damned parking!

If you're lucky enough to find parking on a street without an R-L sign, there's still a 30% chance the goons will ticket your car anyway. And for what violation? Who knows - the citations in cop scrawl on wilted, damp paper are unreadable. Cars are a nice perk in Chicago if you have a reliable parking spot, and you don't need to drive them anywhere but the grocery store.

It's too bad my 99% reliance on the CTA isn't something I can boast of to my car-trapped California friends. Nope! Chicago's public transit system is designed and operated on a the premise of a long forgotten Soviet-era joke. Seriously - escalators that go up but not down? A non-working pay phone at every 4th station? Californians often ask me, "Wow you don't have to drive to work? That's great. How long does it take you to get there?" And I have to answer honestly, "Well it takes anywhere from twenty minutes to over an hour. You just never know."

I like my job that brought me here, but the day business of dealing with the city itself is a job in itself.

The demographic most likely to read Chicagoist may not drive everywhere, but in my experience most people outside that demographic do. Most people at my girlfriend's current place of employment in the Loop drive, as do most people at her former workplace in Streeterville. Management at my workplace all drive. It's almost as if Chicago people reach a certain age and develope el sickness, so they all go out and buy Audis.

And yeah, I'm 100 percent behind this study. Chicago is definitely the most stressful place I've ever lived.

Ditto. Though I was raised here, I've lived other places as well. Since returning a few years ago, I am surprised at how often I find things to be so damned difficult here.

The worst part is that the stress makes me angry, which turns me mean, which comes out as irrational, self-righteous bullshit about who was REALLY next in line at the grocery store, which then raises the stress level of whomever I've just gotten snarky with. Thus, a cycle is born.

I do love this city--I love my job and that my family is nearby--I just don't think I'm tough enough to live here.


user-pic

i ditto a lot of comments. I do have to say depending where you live in chicago there are some escapes. lakefront, caldwell lilly pool, north pond near peggy noterbart nature museum. but the city is too crowded..never been to NYC though. i have to say i really don't like that it's so hard to get away from it..burb after burb, all those highways...

I've lived all over the country in 13 different cities in every corner of the US and I love Chicago. I think this study is crazy, especially when comparing to LA. I lived in LA for two years and eight years later (all spent in Chicago) I still feel a huge sense of relief and calm every time I get on the train, knowing I am not stuck in LA traffic. Of course, the stress does come up when the train mysteriously stops in the middle of nowhere or when it's so packed in the winter that you can't cram another body on so you have to wait out in the arctic winds for the next win. But even given that, it beats most other cities in quality of life.

I came in here to defend Chicago, because I'm usually the biggest Chicago apologist I've ever met, but yeah, this place is rough.

But there are plenty of little things that happen here that make me glad I live here.

- Stumbling into a random street festival

- Dining al fresco on the first warm day of the year

- Ice skating in the snow at millennium park.

I guess I'm trying to cheer myself up after an SUV ran me off the road on my bike and into a pole. Dislocated elbow and broken arms are pretty damn stressful.

user-pic

Any big city is stressful, including this one. There is heightened competition in nearly everything...to be cool, successful, fit a billion things in...plus all the driving/parking/shopping issues everyone mentions. Plus, you are surrounded by honking cars, traffic, millions of people.

I sometimes think about moving to a beach town!

I think the thing most stressful to me is the way everyone is on edge all the time. I grew up in a smaller town and people were just less competitive, generally. Although Chicago is still eons ahead of L.A., from what I hear. Imagine being surrounded by a million aspiring movie stars (I'M going to be the center of attention! NO, I AM!!!). Please shoot me.

I agree completely with Beafraid, Ingrid and Natalie. As another Chicago native, I'm dismayed by the influx of people moving here who are just...(sorry, there's not a polite way to say this) ASSHOLES over the past ten years. I remember when Chicago used to actually be friendly.


Now there's too many people who have fooled themselves into thinking the facade they put on everyday to keep up with their neighbors/coworkers/frenemies is real, and being a rude prick is "just the way to be" in a big city. And it's not.

Chicago is also one of the most segregated cities in America, which makes it very difficult to make and cultivate lasting friendships with different races. Why? Because most of the people here rather just socialize with their own race. And I won't go into the subtle racist attitudes many Chicagoans exhibit...especially from the white population.

LA always gets the bum rap. Sigh. What's to hate about year-round farmers' markets, cheap express busses, and Christmas Eve on the beach?

One thing that's been pissing me off about Chicago is the aldermanic system, the governor who runs up the middle of the street in Lincoln Square like a jackass, and the idea of the fucking Olympics. Also, how cops don't pull to the side of the road when they pull folks over; they just stop in the middle of the road.

Otherwise, go Chicago.

"I'm dismayed by the influx of people moving here who are just...(sorry, there's not a polite way to say this) ASSHOLES over the past ten years. I remember when Chicago used to actually be friendly."


What? Chicago has always been the most backstabbing, player hating, don't-become-successful-or-I'll-take-you-out place ever. I've lived here my whole life. Real Chicagoans are nice enough, but don't ever flaunt your wealth or they'll bring you down to size.

One thing I do like about new york is that you are free to be whoever you want. nobody cares. Chicago, not so much. If you dress flamboyantly, act out of character or are just a well traveled or cultured person you are going to be hated.

My goodness, the comments on here miss the point. You know this survey is idiotic because it lists SAN DIEGO as one of the most stressful in the country. That is a very clear clue that this is a stupid exercise.

And frankly, stressful is what you make of it. I don't find Chicago stressful. I think a lot of people are projecting issues they have in their own lives on to the city (I'm looking at you Matty, thatsright, A2, and Ingrid). Still, if Chicago is the most stressful place for you that you have ever lived, nobody can deny that.

Personally, I found Urbana/Champaign much more stressful. Nowhere to go. Nothing to do. Terrible food. Exams. Crappy apartments. Ugh. I would rather live in the Chi any day. I can handle traffic, parking, and not caring what people think of me.

I'm sure that San Diego, with its tons of pot, fish tacos and love of Bob Marley's "Legend," actually is stressful.

In New York I noticed that people generally don't put people in categories there. It's one of the things I miss the most about that city.

I've lived in Chicago long enough, and been to New York enough times for work and pleasure, to note this, based only on my own experiences: Chicagoans are ruder than New Yorkers. And I'm even a native Midwesterner who half-believed some of the stereotypes about New Yorkers.

Again, just my own experiences.

I am a transplant from the East Coast, went to college in Chicago, then lived in New York City. New York is by far the more stressful place to live in my experience. What a tough to live place to live in. It was hard to meet decent people, have access to creative pursuits without paying an arm and a leg, pay a reasonable rent, feel safe, and live in a place where there were no alleys so garbage was right outside your door (I dare anyone to visit NYC in July and August and tell me the stench of a garbage dump didn't end up on their clothes and hair and in their apartments). It took me two years to feel comfortable and actually admit New York was ok. The next year I left and came back to my first love, Chicago.

I find Chicago more accessible and thus, less stressful (or in the alternative, stress is more manageable) on lots of levels: if I want to go to a show, I have a wide choice entertainment from free to expensive; rents for what I want in an apartment are definitely reasonable; people are easy to meet and are friendlier (might be the circles I run with - no trixie and chad bars for me, thanks); and the lake and the green space are much more accessible (it was tough to remember Manhattan was an island, what with the concrete canyons). Sure, there are stresses when you a large concentration of population (rats in the cage...), and I do miss the opportunity to hop on the Amtrak and get to DC or Boston or points in between to get out of NYC. But, Chicago, my adopted hometown, is where I am most comfortable being. Parking issues, snow days, can't find a decent bagel without going to Skokie, roll-your-eyes-at-the-latest-ban-an-alderman-proposes and all.

Chicago, will you marry me?

Chicago is great, I love it and we have the best band going.... Mr. Blotto. They kick ass.

Totally agree with Jels. Grew up on the east coast, came here for college, moved to New York, and couldn't wait to get back to Chicago. Way less stressful here, cultural activities are way more accessible, and higher quality of life. That said, all of my friends in Chicago are East Coast transplants. Native Chicagoans are generally boring and provincial. It's also hilarious how many Chicago suburbanites escape to New York City and think so highly of their adopted hometown (and themselves). They have bad memories of waiting outside for a school bus in some anonymous midwestern suburb and then feel entitled to belittle a city they know little to nothing about (since most leave Chicago at 18 to attend college on the coasts and never look back). The truth is that midwesterners are just as boring in New York City as they are in Chicago. Midwesterners just aren't as fun as east coast kids IMO. Chicago is great though, as long as your hang with people from elsewhere.

The truth is that midwesterners are just as boring in New York City as they are in Chicago.

I prefer "grounded" and "unpretentious" to "boring"--that's my experience of east coast kids who brag, however mildly and politely, about being from the east coast--but hey, I'm the type of person who likes to get home early so I can watch "Matlock," so perhaps I am not the best judge.

I've found that coping with the everyday stressors of Chicago life makes me a calmer, kinder person overall. It teaches me to keep things in perspective and makes me more likely to empathize when someone else is having a bad day. If I let some of the everyday crap get to me, I'd be walking the streets in abject misery. In Chicago, kindness and patience are often the cheapest and most effective coping mechanisms.

Chicagoist, on the other hand, is easily one of the most stressful websites in the country. And I have not yet learned to cope with some of the comments properly ... at least not on a consistent basis.

@matilda:

Maaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaatlock!

In defense of Forbes (eieew), I have to put two more of my cents into this by saying: I'm going to have a handicapped-out-of-town guest in for the weekend.

The weekend isn't even here yet and I'm already stressed to the max trying to figure out which CTA station's elevators are actually operational and which downtown areas have ramps etc.

I agree with alot of the comments here about Chicago being such a friendly city. Granted, the fact that it is the 3rd largest metropolitan area in the US - and it is a Northern city - people do tend to keep to themselves and can be rude and direct at times. But - isn't any big city like that? I live in the Washington, DC area which I really enjoy, because it's definitely one of the friendlier places in the East Coast/Northeastern corridor. Although I love NY and Boston, etc - people there, especially NY are EXTREMELY stressed out. I am from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania originally which kind of has this weird East coast/midwest/appalacian mix - so I'm used to it all. Travel 3 hours east, and you are in Balt/DC east coast. Travel 2 hours northwest, and you are in Cleveland, which is definitely midwest. By far - NYC is the most stressful place I've ever been. Millions of people, in a big fat hurry to get everywhere. I mean I love it - but there is NO WAY Chicago is more stressful, no way. I love Chicago, and I have family there. For a big city, Chicago is one of the nicest friendliest places I've been. And I agree with one of the comments about Chicago suburbanites moving to NYC and then kind of making it like their own - they are not from NYC anymore than I am or ever will be; yet, I've met some of these people that are from ChiTown, have moved to the East coast - and try to tell ME about my city where I grew up, Pittsburgh. Granted - have they ever been there? NO! So, shut the F up and stick to what you know about. You can say whatever you want if you've been there, I'm fine with that. hey- I moved away so I know alot about that city sucks. But - there are also alot of nice things about it too: such as, you can actually drive to the beach for a weekend if you want - sorry Chicagoan, lake michigan doesn't count. Also, we have the Top ski resort in the Mid-Atlantic only one hour away because there are actual mountain ranges - not like the flat, cornfield midwest. I mean, where the hell do you guys go skiing? You probably have to get on a plane. anyways, sorry about that - some bad encounters with people I had to get off my chest.

One story I'd like to relate: In college, I once took the bus from Pittsburgh to visit a girlfriend in Northern NJ, which is basically NYC. when I was returning home, I went to the ticket counter to get a train ticket from Metuchen, NJ to NY Penn Station where I could catch the bus. I asked the guy for a one way ticket to Penn Station. so, the guy hands me a ticket to Penn STation - in Newark, NJ. So, I said no I meant NY. The guy blew up at me, and said "why didn't you say that in the first place?" and I said to him, well maybe its because I'm not from around here and I didn't realize anyone would be stupid enough to name two train stations that are only 8 miles apart the same F'ing name. Then, I said to him "Merry Christmas pal." Another thing is that when driving on 95 and you have to go through the tolls (or I-80, whatever) in the NY area - if you say anything to the toll collector, they will not say a word back to you at all. NY is definitley the most stressful by far. This study sucks.

Northern NJ, which is basically NYC

Obviously you are not a bowler.


I grew up in NYC and I would never want to go back except to visit. For starters, it is crowded, expensive and generally too much. I had lived in Chicago for 2 years before economics forced me to move. I miss Chicago. I won't deny that it is stressful, but the worst part is the transportation: the traffic and the El. Here's why I miss Chicago though: the people. A lot of the comments center on the people- both the good and the bad- and I have met both types. I'll tell you though that two years is a very short time, and I have made a lot of good friends in Chicago! Also: I cannot believe that it is more stressful than NYC! I have done more things in Chicago in NYC because I was less stressed.

However, when people say that Chicagoans are changing, I thought I was the only one; and having lived there for a short time had no right to think that. Chicago is a great place, and although people are people no matter where you go, I just hope this trend is stopped because it would be a real shame. I love you Chicago!

in a response to "jerseydude",its funny how many eastcoasters i have to put in check everytime i somehow manage to meet one of you. i have so called friends from queens and the bx and im telling you like i told them---dont come here to chicago and try to act like you are so much of the s@*t. you obviously coulndt make it in your hometown(ny) so you come here(chi)and try to act like your the toast of the town. and arent you from jersey? from what i hear, nyorkers dont give a da%m about you anyway. the problem with native nyorkers is that they all want to be more important than what they really are in the presence of other cities. no matter how unimportant they are as a person they think that that they have some sort of "east coast charisma" that makes them more special. and they are really just pretending as usual, most dont really have to much going on, thats why they are acting like well, you "jerseydude". i really dont care that much whos more stressful, i just wanted to respond to this guy whos acting like an east coast don but probably really isnt as vibrant as he says he is

While I bitch and moan at the gas pump as much as the next guy, I don't think we drive nearly as much as this article suggests.

I am not sure about the stress but Chicago is definitely the dumbest city I ever lived in. It's public transportation (trains) will take you anywhere you want, provided you want to go downtown. Both local news papers are of very suspicious journalistic quality and are so uninspiring that they have almost no circulation outside of Chicago. The only national magazine out of Chicago is Playboy. The only TV programming out of Chicago is Ophra. The only three major league sport clubs have won a total of four national titles since their inceptions. Chicago pays the highest sales tax in the country and in returns it gets terrible roads and the worst police and highest crime rates of all big cities in the US.
Most importantly Chicago is full of shallow, boring, unrefined uneducated, close minded, tasteless and totally complacent hicks that allow legendary Chicago corruption and for the same individual to run the city in the past few decades.
Yes, If Chicago is in fact the most stressful city in the US, it is only because the dumb folks here deserve it like nobody else.
Go Cubs!

Chicago was a good choice for most stressful. Other places, like New York, seem like they would be more stressful. But believe it or not, Chicago does have worse weather. It's 10-20 degrees colder in the winter and there are less days of sun all year. Nobody really drives in New York. It's all cabs and subway trains. If you live in Manhatten, well, you are way more well off than any hood rat from Chicago. People from Chicago trying to say that not everyone drives in Chicago?? Why then is it the 2nd worst traffic snarled city, only second to L.A.??? The number of murders in Chicago EXCEEDS the number of murders in New York, a city 5 times larger. Yeh. There are legitimate reasons why Chicago is #1.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

About Chicagoist

Chicagoist is a website about Chicago. More

Editor: Marcus Gilmer
Publisher: Gothamist

Contribute

Latest Photo:

Recent Comments

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Chicagoist.

All Our RSS