Rockin' Our Turntable: Tommy Stinson (and some other dudes)

2008_11_chinese_democracy.jpgTommy Stinson's side project, Guns N' Roses, has finally released the long awaited follow-up to their last album, The Spaghetti Incident. The album has a pristine sound that would have been absolutely perfect and killer ... had it come out in 1998.

Stinson's singer, Axl Rose, is still in fine form, but seems to insist in writing songs bearing so many layers of studio trickery that they no longer resemble musical constructs. Instead they come across as so many high tech Lincoln Logs piled upon each other until they reach the stratosphere and threateningly teeter into the realm of the ridiculous.

Honestly, the first four tracks on the new album -- cunningly titled Chinese Democracy after the impossible standards set by the band's label for their promotion teams -- ain't bad at all. Despite some tired industrial disco beats underlying the rock, the tunes manage to be catchy and break free of the mountains of sheen doing its best to weigh them down. After that, though, things swiftly spiral downward, burdened by misplaced Flamenco guitars, overwrought balladry that would make Meat Loaf hide in shame, and hooks that reach out only to miss just before you tumble off the cliff they've thrown you over.

Depsite all of this, our recommendation is that you buy this album. Why? Because no one makes records like this anymore. We've lost sight of the glory of rock star excess as it's been overshadowed by pop pap and it's reliance on corporate sponsorship and video product placement. You should but this because no one else has the moxie to make their fans wait a decade plus for a new album while seriously thinking they're still relevant (we're not counting The Eagles or My Bloddy Valentine). And, finally, you should buy this because Tommy Stinson could use the dough until Paul Westerberg comes around and finally conceeds to a Replacements reunion tour.*

*And, by all rights, said tour should kick of in Grant Park, to bring that band's life cycle full circle.

Email This Entry


Comments (10) [rss]

despite... despite... despite...

point made ... point made ... point made...

yo are correct regarding tommy stinson. dude oughta be getting paid john mayer cash.

do the newly reunited Faces need a bass guitar player? he's got the hair/vox for them fo' sho.......

Thanks, but I'll stick to Weezer's Red Album for ridiculous over the top bombast and cheese.

Anyone want my free Dr. Pepper on Sunday when the Hired Guns 'N Roses album drops?

Man, that headline got me all excited thinkin' that a new Tommy album was out that I wasn't aware of. Oh well. Back to waitin'.

Better guitar riff?

The riff at the beginning of (about 1 min into) the "chinese democracy" track.

-or-

The riff at the beginning of the 90210 theme song

Discuss.

'The riff at the beginning of the 90210 theme song'

oh dude!

we share the same brain..........

user-pic

You got me, Tankboy! I was all ready to red about Tommy's solo record or some such thing. I keep forgetting that he's in G 'N' R. Mostly, because it still doesn't make much sense to me.

Like a few others, I was excited to see Tommy putting out new work only to find his rent-a-bass project getting a review which if it weren't for Tommy in GNR I wouldn't even pay attention. Remember to get your free Dr. Pepper when this is released!

http://chicagoist.com/2008/11/13/gnr_hits_chicago_early_kinda.php

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

About Chicagoist

Chicagoist is a website about Chicago. More

Editor: Marcus Gilmer
Publisher: Gothamist

Contribute

Latest Tip:

NYT article detailing how the city will spend all of the money from the parking meter lease by 2010.
[more]

Latest Photo:

Recent Comments

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Chicagoist.

All Our RSS