Quantcast

High School Teacher Suspended for Showing Daily Show Clips in Class

2011_11_17_jon_stewart.png
A high school teacher in downstate Illinois has been suspended and reassigned because he showed students scenes from The Daily Show with Jon Stewart. Rhett Felix, sophomore social studies teacher at Eureka High School, was suspended for six days for violating school policy, after parents complained to the school board.

Being a basic cable show, Jon Stewart doesn't drop any real swear words, just some obvious beeps and "motherfudges". In fact, The Daily Show is rated TV-14 L for "coarse language." TV-14 means it may contain material "that many parents would find unsuitable for children under 14 years of age." For the sake of comparison, Family Guy, which airs on network TV, has a rating of TV-14 D, L, S, V -- that means intensely suggestive dialogue (D), strong coarse language (L), intense sexual situations (S), and intense violence (V). That's an adult cartoon, though, not a jokey news show with a liberal slant.

Most high school sophomores are 15-16 years old, which means their parents aren't even supposed to "take caution." However, the town's mayor claims some of its residents don't own televisions "because of religious beliefs." Eureka is a small town of about 5,300 people. It's also home to Eureka College, where President Ronald Reagan studied, and it hosts the Reagan Museum and Peace Garden.

The Tribune said the teacher showed three segments and that those "dealt with the sexual harassment allegations against GOP presidential candidate Herman Cain and with the issue of health insurance discounts for exercising." The Tribune writes:

“We’re a very conservative community here in the city of Eureka,” (Eureka Mayor Scott) Punke said of the town about 30 miles northwest of Bloomington. “Certainly politics are playing a part, but my main concern is they are showing inappropriate material with language and dealing with sex to minors in a school setting.”

It appears the teacher showed segments from the Oct. 31 and Nov. 2 episodes. In the first episode, Stewart does make a crack about the pizza industry being sexually suggestive by nature, saying, "I guarantee you, I will come in 30 minutes or less," then correspondent Wyatt Cenac gives a pretty comprehensive lesson on what kills a bill, specifically outside interest groups. The Bloomington Pantagraph also reported that parents took issue with a mention in the Nov. 2 episode of "a prominent politician whose name turns up in Internet searches as an obscene term." (That'd be a Rick Santorum.)

The Pantagraph writes:

Parent Thomas Enterline of Goodfield said he found the material "deplorable."

"I didn't find any humor in what I saw," he said. "I look at what happened out at Penn State. Even though this doesn't rise to that particular level, I would ask that this board look at these allegations and respond with appropriate resolve."

Once again bringing politics into play, parents say Felix "regularly criticized conservative politicians and praised liberals." The clips the teacher showed the classroom are below. The first is a clip from the Oct. 31 episode of Stewart ragging on Cain, then Cenac's segment on a failed bill to decrease healthcare premiums for those who exercise, followed by a Nov. 2 segment, also about Herman Cain.



Contact the author of this article or email tips@chicagoist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • what??? i grew up in Eureka - and went to that high school. I only wish Mr. Felix had been teaching there when I was in school (or that the Daily Show had been on in the mid to late 80s). Eureka and the consolidated communities in that area (Goodfield and Congerville) are extremely conservative - so I can't say I'm surprised by this reaction - but comparing this to Penn State issues? Let's get some true perspective people.

  • What?!?!?!?! Stewart has a unique point of view (although I suspect it's more
    the writing staff then him personally), that is no more biased then fox,
    nbc/msnbc or even the 700 club. These bungholes in ILLINOIS ( the state that
    produces more corrupt politicians then Italy) want the schools to be tolerant
    and support anti-bully laws, promotion of gay culture, and who knows what else,
    but they draw the line at comedy? WOW!!!!!!

    BTW if someone from Stewart's
    staff is reading this, I'm looking for a new gig.....

  • ChicagoD

    I like the fact that all of your posts have the same breathless, senseless quality. You're allowing your inner pedo to shine all across the web. What time are visiting hours where you are?

  • oonagh1

    Yeah, keep looking...

    Also, I believe you are comparing Illinois to Italy, so,  you need to use "than". "Then" connotes when something happened.  In other words, what you are stating is that Illinois has produced more corrupt politicians since Italy, which does not make any sense, really.

  • slickpoetry

     thank you for your reasoned, well-thought out commentary, Pedo Lawyer.

    I sure do love cross-posting...

  • slickpoetry

    Yeah, I mean...I don't find the Daily Show offensive in the slightest. And yet...I don't think that it should take the place of actual instruction in a Social Studies high school classroom--regardless of whether or not the community is "liberal" or "conservative." Unless the purpose of the class is studying, I don't know.....jokes. 

  • slickpoetry

    The suspension is a bit of an overreach though, for this situation...

  • ChicagoD

    1. If Eureka thinks this is bad wait until the kids try to dance at the prom.

    2. Listen to twocee, she's right on both counts.

  • twocee

    What would Kevin Bacon do?

  • ChicagoD

    He'd have to cut loose. Footloose.

  • twocee

    Parents of Eureka:  Kick off your Sunday shoes.

  • John Lithgow is unamused.

  • twocee

    1 - comparing any of this to anything that happened at Penn State is deplorable, and Thomas Enterline should be ashamed for doing so.

    2 - although I personally find nothing wrong with my teenagers watching the Daily Show, I can't really say I would find it appropriate to show it in school.  Not for anything Jon Stewart says, but I simply think there are better things to be spending teaching time on than a Comedy Central show.  However, suspending the teacher is a WEE bit of an overreaction.  Get a grip, parents of Eureka.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@chicagoist.com