More on Comments 2.0: Come on out of the Shadows

2007_07_Speak_No_Evil.jpgBy now you know that we've rolled out a new comments system here at Chicagoist. After a week, it's working pretty well for us, we have to say.

Now, one of the things you might be noticing is "guest" comments are posting in a lighter font that those of registered commenters (James, our copy editor, says this is the correct spelling, but we're gonna have to dust off a couple dictionaries to be certain). This post is a friendly reminder to everyone that we really want you to register and create a profile for Comments 2.0.

The main goal behind this system is to generate better comments, sure. But we're also trying to foster a sense of community among our readership. Registering in Comments 2.0 will give you more of a presence on Chicagoist. We're also hoping that it brings everyone together to produce more meaningful comments about our content, dialogue with our staff and each other; no more re-reading which "guest" said what before you fire off a reply. Registering in Comments 2.0 will also have some added benefits as we roll out more new technological features here at Chicagoist in the coming weeks. It's a minor hassle right now, but it comes with lots of benefits.

  • You have to register once, and only once.
  • It takes less than a minute to sign up and confirm your membership, from start to finish. Seriously.
  • You're identified by the name of your choice when you post a comment on an article rather than as a "guest."
  • There's no annoying "CAPTCHA" (those things where you have to type in what letters or numbers you see in a box) if you want to comment, even as a guest, and our system is way better than some other sites': across Gawker Media sites, for instance, you can't simply register — you have to post a comment that the administrators really, really like and only then will they approve your account.
  • You stay logged in, both on Chicagoist and across the Gothamist network.
  • You get your own fancy-dancy profile page that lists your recent comments (and responses to those comments). Like this. Or this.
  • If you already had a Typekey account that you used to comment on Chicagoist, you can simply import all your old comments made under it to the new system.
  • It all but cuts off comment spam, which is good for us, but even better for you — comments should show up much quicker, and there shouldn't be any of those frustrating delays or double-posted comments.

Ultimately, what we're asking for is that you not be strangers. You have the right to register as a "guest," but it's our opinion that registering in Comments 2.0 will build a stronger community of staff and readers. Please don't be shy.

Wayne Shorter's "Speak No Evil" album cover image courtesy of Wikipedia. Classic album, by the way.

Email This Entry


Comments (19) [rss]

I just want to see how this works.

and collecting emails of readers for sale to third party advertisers (i.e. spammers) has /nothing/ to do with it at all. nope.

You know what happens when one assumes, right, guest #2?

Like I wrote, if you want to keep registering as a guest, that's your right. If you or anyone else wants to discuss this or any other concerns regarding the new comments feature you can always e-mail me directly. I'll gladly answer any questions, and we'll do our best to alleviate any concerns.

Greying out the 'guests' comments so I can ignore them is a big plus as well.

Guest forevah!

I will fight the power!

You shall not make me register Chicagoistas!

This is a test. Game on, Holmes.

You know, because Chicagoist wants to steal your money/soul/life.

Or we just want to make it so you can comment.

And for the record, I do want to state that we're not collecting your data so spammers can get to you when you register. If you start receiving European Union lotto award notices, "419" scams, or "get-a-free-iPod" e-mails, it wasn't because of Chicagoist.

Cool?

i don't want chicagoist to know who i am!

Yes, by all means, use the new comments system...Just don't be critical of Chicagoist. They don't like that.

That Wayne Shorter record kicks azz!

Didn't you need to submit an e-mail before commenting on the old system?!?? Just register already!

Gee, you Chicagoist folks sure are touchy, aren't you?

Since you've already made an ass of yourself, Chuck, I'll complete the circle by assuming this is just a good way to tally unique visitors, better than hit counts. I'm no new economy hipster hoping to be bought out by Google, but I would guess being able to proclaim a certain number of registered users would be a great excuse for charging American Apparel that much more for display ads featuring bad photos of prepubescent girls in skimpy underwear, never mind the annoyance to those users.

I'm just tired of giving my name to every random web site on the planet, so I'm not doing it anymore. Create as much community as you want ... I'm happy to be a guest in it.

Of course this is related to ad rates. Community is secondary.

If this isn't related to ad rates, then you guys really need to get on the boat, as you are missing out.

Guests unite! I agree, sick of registering for every site on the planet. I'll just be a second class citizen who makes everyone else have to squint with my comments.

I can't get the TypeKey reclamation thingy to work at all. I've entered username/email, just username, and just email. Each results in a page saying that a reset link will be emailed, but nothing ever arrives. Am I doing something wrong?

- bopo

They're more interested in looking up your past comments and saying, "See -- you totally sounded like you're willing to buy into every random trend and ridiculous thing in that one comment you left long ago...just like us! Except that we're really, really sensitive about everything hip because we want to be in front of the pack, in a months behind kind of way, but we'll pretend like we're right on top of things anyway, and wonder why you can't appreciate our lack of "getting it", while we tell you we "get it" anyway..", and why aren't you getting it like everybody else? Since we do..

I am suddenly stuck as 'guest' how the hell do I sign out?

- vit

As guests #13 and #14 have already noted, forced registration is typically about making money. It increases the value of site in terms of loyal readership.

Just be honest, Chuck, and tell it how it is. This isn't about 'community' and 'not being strangers.' It's about charging advertisers and increasing the value of the site.

I love this site, but I don't like to register. Sorry.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

About Chicagoist

Chicagoist is a website about Chicago. More

Editor: Marcus Gilmer
Publisher: Gothamist

Contribute

Latest Tip:

KOI ... pet fish you can really pet !
[more]

Latest Photo:

Recent Comments

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Chicagoist.

All Our RSS