Extra, Extra

2007_09tinajon.jpg




"El Tinajon" by rachelleb

Email This Entry


Comments (7) [rss]

"Most of the water in the Chicago River is treated sewage that is loaded with bacteria..."

If one of my students used a quote like this without providing a source I would give them an F but Chicagoist-and I'm sure other web sites- quotes directly from a source with no apparent concern. This is interesting in our new Reader's Digest-like era where news stories are constantly lifted, parsed, and linked to so frequently. Do the rules of research and journalism no longer apply? Who gets credit when that same sentence is used again elsewhere? Chicagoist? Things that make you say hmmm...

Between the river and Lake Michigan, we are seeing a return of the Lake Erie episode.

#1, wasn't the Tribune in the link? That's the source.

Most of the water in the Chicago River is treated sewage loaded with bacteria.

Direct quote from the Chicago Tribune.

Perhaps Guest Number One would like Chicagoist to start supplying endnotes and bibliographies?

I'm pretty sure #1's beef is not the validity of the statement, but as you said -- all the text after the initial question is a "direct quote", but there's nary a quotation mark.

I'm not harping (as I am #1) so much as pondering the new age of journalism we are in. Endnotes? Not necessary. Quotes? Yes, even if the source is given. At least at the University where I teach. Doesn't matter if you provide a source, if you don't quote, it's plagiarism. Doesn't seem to me like it's asking too much to have original authors be given credit for THEIR work. I don't file share either, perhaps I'm just wound too tight.

Stop swimming in the river, idiots..

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

About Chicagoist

Chicagoist is a website about Chicago. More

Editor: Marcus Gilmer
Publisher: Gothamist

Contribute

Latest Tip:

NYT article detailing how the city will spend all of the money from the parking meter lease by 2010.
[more]

Latest Photo:

Recent Comments

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Chicagoist.

All Our RSS