October 7, 2008
Police Reveal More Info In CTA Shooting
Police have revealed more information on Sunday night's CTA shooting that left an innocent 17-year-old dead. Kiyanna Salter was sitting with her cousin, Jasmine Wilcox, on the No. 71 bus Sunday, talking to a man on the bus the two had just met. At that point, another man accidentally touched the man's hand hand as he was exiting the bus. And that's all it took. The two men argued briefly and both flashed guns in an apparent (and now traditional) show of machismo. As the man exiting the bus finally got off, he turned and fired into the bus. But instead of striking his intended target, the bullets hit Kiyanna, killing her instantly. Jasmine said, "I didn't know it was her who got shot until they said somebody got shot. I happened to look up, and it was just her laying there. I just went to her and grabbed her hand. I just grabbed her hand."
Now, as Kayanna's family deals with this unspeakable tragedy, police begin searching for the shooter and have released stills from the bus's surveillance camera (pictured right). Kiyanna was staying with Jasmine and her family while she finished her studies at Julian High School; her mother had recently moved to Bartlett. Kiyanna's aunt, Tara Bruce, said:
It's too much. It's too much. Nobody deserves to bury their child for a senseless crime because you're angry at somebody...[It's wrong] to pick up a gun and decide to fire it and you don't know where those bullets are going to land...My niece was not only beautiful on the outside, she was truly a beautiful young lady on the inside. She wanted the best for everybody.
We know we've complained here before about the cramped conditions of the CTA before, wedged into rush hour Red lines, but this is abso-fucking-lutely ridiculous. An accidental touch? Let it go, just let it fucking go. Here's hoping they catch the shooter and that in some form or fashion, both men involved are held responsible. If you have any information on the shooting, contact Chicago Police or Cook County Crime Stoppers at (800) 535-7867.



[ report this ]
You know what? F* it, public hanging in Daley Plaza. He deserves it.
[ report this ]
I'm sick of all these BS machismo displays. I say catch him, and have a public hanging in Daley Plaza. He deserves it.
[ report this ]
I wonder what would happend if the country thought that youth violence was as important as bailing out wall street?
[ report this ]
The Tribune is really run by a bunch of greedy bastards. At least the Chicagoist was able to provide some somewhat usable images of this ass hole. On the Trib website (see the link above) you have to watch a 15 second commercial before you see 3 seconds of the shooter. Want to see it again? Watch another commercial. Not only that but the video they do show is close to useless. Tribune: If you want people to ID this guy don't be so money grubbing.
[ report this ]
Here's a trickle down for you. When pit bull hockey moms and raving reverends spread homophobia far and wide, this kind of bullshit is the result. No, I'm not hysterical enough to draw a direct line from Sarah Palin talking about "the choice" GLBTQ people make to this, but when you tolerate bigotry, when you make it perfectly acceptable use words about GLBTQs that are as offensive as racial slurs, when you raise hell every few years to keep 'the gays' from getting married, is is surprising that it trickles down as another excuse for violence?
Nah. Just a coincidence I'm sure.
[ report this ]
And it's because of animals like this that I support the death penalty. Hell, we should use it more often, a bullet to the back of the head. People like this have no business living in society. [Yeah, I know about the massive mistakes made with the death penalty, and those have to be fixed, but I really see no reason to allow such creatures, assuming they are convicted, to live among civilized people. Some people are just lost causes.]
Dopplerd: Well, the Trib has to make money somehow, especially when so many people read its stories for free on the Web.
[ report this ]
Chicagoist posted an article awhile back that was a recap of an NYT magazine article whose thesis was basically, "Let's stop treating urban violence like a moral issue, let's start treating it like a health issue".
I totally agree with Spook. If we gave just 1% of the bailout money to education etc on urban violence, incidents like these would be so few and far between.
Also: it's the economy stupid. People are on edge etc...it's like a powder keg out there. And when you're already poor, just makes it worse.
[ report this ]
"Well, the Trib has to make money somehow, especially when so many people read its stories for free on the Web."
So its o.k for the Trib to make a buck off "such" a creature"?
People like you are worse Rattilda because I can only guess what produced this person. Not that you genuflect on such social matters instead of defending a b.s republican rag of a news paper
See its you that have no excuse to be such a lost cause.
As flawded as I am, to want to see a bullet in this child killers head. I would rather force you to trade places with him. He gets your opportunities at birth and you get his.
[ report this ]
Spook: We should work harder to prevent people from becoming such creatures. No doubt. But there comes a time when we have to cut our losses, where the greater need for safety outweighs any empathy or pity for lost causes. And don't play the "trading places" crap, either: Many people are able to make it out of bad situations. Life is unfair. And you also assume I had such great prospects at birth (wrong, pal), or that this killer had none. Can you ever make an argument here without relying on assumptions? For all we know, this killer had a loving mom and dad, as many killers and amoral or immoral people do.
And if you are reading the Trib stories for free, you really have no right to complain. The Trib is a business, after all, and you are simply arguing for the right to mooch.
[ report this ]
GLBTQ people make to this,
Ok, call me ignorant. I know what the "GLBT" stand for, but when did "Q," get invited, and what does he stand for.
[ report this ]
Ron Huberman "Safety is job 1. Now give me my police pension!"
[ report this ]
Q stands for "Queer", and it's something of a popular designation. I tend to simply call people by their names, not their orientations, but in this case it's short hand.
The study mentioned above can be found here, I believe.
http://www.allacademic.com/meta/p_mla_apa_research_citation/2/0/1/1/1/p201110_index.html
[ report this ]
JD84, the Q stands for Queer.
[ report this ]
Q can be Queer or Questioning.. the letters are ever expanding.
As far as the story.. how can one be so quick to fire over something so stupid? Is this the wild west? The guys must resort to gun displays frequently if they whip them out so easily in a public place.
[ report this ]
What angers me so much about this case is the machismo/homophobia that seems to have started the whole thing. An accidental bump/touch? Really? That leads to the shooting death of an innocent 17 year old???
[ report this ]
For all we know, this killer had a loving mom and dad, as many killers and amoral or immoral people do.
No, Rattida that's just an example of how creatures like YOU put social blinders on your cow face to avoid what's going on in the growing dark underside in urban communities of "your" America
Yea what "we" know is that you are a pompous moron, no better than the child killer. Now here is your Baby Eichmann Award, now please go choke on it in your corner of stupidity.
"Let's stop treating urban violence like a moral issue, let's start treating it like a health issue".
Sorry Jenny wrong Country be it McCain or O'bama leading us. The misfortunes of these children will continue to be the only economic boom in the U.S.
[ report this ]
Really? That leads to the shooting death of an innocent 17 year old???
The currency of kids like this is their reputation. Someone calls you a name or bumps into you on the street, you brush it off, make a joke of it. Because you have other standards of success, a job, a family, friends. But at the ragged edge these kids live on you are only as valued as you can claim and defend. So yeah, someone touches you, bumps into you, you've got to take a stand, or else the next "insult" could be that much greater.
I don't mean to make it sound glorious or even 'tough'. It's pathetic and desperate. Add homophobia to that, add a body proud gun culture and frankly it's surprising we don't see more of this.
[ report this ]
Q stands for "Queer", and it's something of a popular designation. I tend to simply call people by their names, not their orientations, but in this case it's short hand.
thanks, and I know I'm off-topic here, but this confuses me. What's the difference between queer and gay? I was under the belief that they were somewhat interchangeable.
[ report this ]
"What angers me so much about this case is the machismo/homophobia that seems to have started the whole thing."
When you have been indoctrinated from birth to hate yourself, you are always looking for some one else to hate more. Freak-O's like Rev/Sen. Meeks provide convenient targets with gays, but of course you hate what mostly looks like you. Franz Fanon taught us this, or at least taught me this.
[ report this ]
No, Rattida that's just an example of how creatures like YOU put social blinders on your cow face to avoid what's going on in the growing dark underside in urban communities of "your" America
Yea what "we" know is that you are a pompous moron, no better than the child killer. Now here is your Baby Eichmann Award, now please go choke on it in your corner of stupidity.
For the love of all that is holy, will you stop with the stupid name calling of other posters, please? It adds nothing. Your ideas stand or fall on their own. Some of us can debate and exchange ideas, and do so in a heated manner, without calling each other names. I suggest you learn how to do so.
And, besides, I would love to run into you and have you try to equate my idea with giving the death penalty to thug killers who can't shoot straight as being the same as supporting racial-superiority theories and the genocide of millions (and it's not even your own words, but Ward Churchill's, the whole Baby Eichmann bit.) Calling me a Nazi, a member of the death-camp structure, is offensive, even for you. Trust me, you would not do that in person, or you would not hide behind the Internet here.
[ report this ]
Stupid and senseless.
[ report this ]
What's the difference between queer and gay?
Preference really. I know some more politically active people like Queer as a term because it's more 'aggressive', the chant from the 80's and 90's "We're here, we're queer, get used to it". There's an element of reclaiming the word too.
Homosexual is very clinical, gay is pretty neutral.
[ report this ]
#4 I emailed one of the addresses on the trib's site and restated your complaint. I think you are right that it is a shame that the commercial for walter e. smithe is longer than the image of the perpetrator.
[ report this ]
I'm not surprised that the resident social experts on here are deflecting blame from the idiot involved in the shooting and passing it onto society. Hundreds of thousands of people - many of which in the same socioeconomic position as this guy - ride CTA buses every day. The overwhelming majority of them don't end up shooting somebody on the bus over an argument. To blame this on society, homophobia, powerlessness, etc. is just ignorant.
[ report this ]
Personally, there's no excuse anyone could give for what this bum did that would satisfy me or make me have an iota of sympathy. Even the child soldiers of Uganda, no matter how much they have been FORCED to do in their short lives, express grief and regret if they have the opportunity to leave that situation and they grow up with WAY less than this piece of sh*t. For God's sake, the guy has new Timberlands on. How "deprived" can his life be?
[ report this ]
To blame this on society, homophobia, powerlessness, etc. is just ignorant.
How profound.
Societal forces don't excuse individual behavior. No one is arguing that, no one sane. The argument is 'how can we address these problems on a larger scale?' and dealing with broad trends and issues is a way to do that. An after-school program might prevent 50 kids from going a bad route, attempts to educate poor young black men on alternatives to violence in resolving conflicts or getting them into job training might stop a few dozen more. But because it's preventative and not punative the loud and loutish among us will call it "soft" and demand more prisons and more cops as the only solutions. Y'know, ignorance.
[ report this ]
but because it's preventative and not punative the loud and loutish among us will call it "soft" and demand more prisons and more cops as the only solutions.
Very good, if obvious, point. I think you have to do both: Attack the problem at the roots, yet be prepared to cut off the bad growth if needed. Sorry for the bad metaphor, but you can't have one without the other if you expect to make any change, I think.
[ report this ]
Very good, if obvious, point.
Don't be unpleasant.
Everyone on here is tired of nonsense from me and surely from you. Do better.
[ report this ]
Albany: I wasn't trying to be unpleasant, but I can how that came across as insulting. Remember, tone is often lost on blogs.
How about this: Sometimes we need to be reminded of the most obvious points, as we tend to forget. That is what I was trying to say.
I hope you do better as well. No more name calling or personal insults of other posters. Do I have your word on that? You certainly have mine.
[ report this ]
Uhm Matilda,
Ward Churchill didn't mean/define "little Eichmann" -his exact term- as supporters of "racial-superiority theories" and the "genocide of millions"
nor did he call them Nazi's or members of a death camp structure per say. He was talking about American apathy and ignorance to what the American power structure is doing to poor folks both here and abroad. This is the exact way I used it. And I would stand by my remarks both in person and on the internet.
And you say that Albany made and "obvious point" but these are points you are never able to make. You are against "populism" yet cloak yourself in it as part of your current cyber identity so that you can be welcomed and raise a shot and a beer with Jimbo and the rest of the Bridgeport crew
[ report this ]
So let me get this straight, Albany - you want after school programs and education programs for conflict resolution......for those that most likely aren't attending school. Do you see the problem with your argument?
And Albany - in your first post, you placed the blame on society - so I wouldn't play coy if I was in your position.
[ report this ]
Spook: You called me a death-camp functionary--or, I'm sorry, someone just like him--for calling for the death penalty against apparently nihilistic killers who murder innocent people. And then you, as you typically do, call someone ignorant who does not share you psuedo-revolutionary view of the world. (Notice the word psuedo--that is key there, Spook.)
Besides being offensive, the Eichmann reference makes no sense in this case.
Perhaps you were so bold because you are used to arguing with people who are ignorant of history, or who can't think critically. You can disagree with my views all you want, but saying I am like Eichmann 1) betrays your lack of knowledge about the Nazi state and its workings; 2) serves as a shortcut to thought and analysis.
"Bridgeport crew"? What on earth are you saying? Or, am I actually supposed to be insulted by that? Again, you swing for the fences and miss. I can't imagine I've been to Bridgeport in more than a year.
And I would stand by my remarks both in person and on the internet.
Uh, you didn't say that in person, and we both know you would not toss out such a reckless insult to someone's face--at the least, you would leave a real name here instead of some cheap handle. Trust me, if you saw me in person, you would know what I mean.
So, again, can you engage in debate without insults or name calling? Are you smart enough? I think you are. Let's see.
[ report this ]
If you kids don't calm down, I'm going to unplug the internets.
[ report this ]
UPDATE: Playing the video on the Trib site no longer plays a commercial. Matty and myself had emailed to complain that watching the 3 second clip required watched a 15 second commercial each time.
I have no problem with advertising but that seemed rather inappropriate. Plus, I don't think many advertisers would want to be the lead in to surveillance footage of a murderer.
[ report this ]
So let me get this straight, Albany - you want after school programs and education programs for conflict resolution......for those that most likely aren't attending school. Do you see the problem with your argument?
Your solution being what? More cops? More tactical units? More jails?
I'm for intervention from birth on. You draw a line here and say NO to another lost generation of kids. Parenting intervention, education reform, economic development, a community effort to keep kids on track. Right now it's all scatter shot.
Listen to this podcast
http://www.thisamericanlife.org/Radio_Episode.aspx?sched=1262
and read about the program
http://www.hcz.org/
97% of kids in this program scored at or above grade level for math. NINETY-SEVEN. That's not even the first whole class.
More cops, more squads, more militarization is...not...working. Time for something better. And if it doesn't sit right with your reagan-era bootstrap john wayne mythos, too bad.
[ report this ]
Broomtilda,
why don't you read what Ward Churchill meant when he coined the term "little Eichmann"
Maybe that will help. And I am calling you a Little/baby Eichmann for being clueless, for turning a blinds eye of the type of country we live in that is producing more and more child killers from birth, especially in certain communities or minorities.
I am calling you Baby Eichmann for tossing around a depleted and empty "pull yourself up by the boot strap" lines and having a typical lack of intellectual and social empathy that you share with the racist whites who live in Bridgeport, the white working class Nascar/joe six pack crowd that you idolized.
Instead of asking what does it mean for certain children to be born into a certain zip code, attending certain schools where a culture of violence, self hate and despair permeates. What does that culture produce and how do we deal with it as a society.
And I find your isolated insular looking down name calling death penalty rants insulting to a community that you have not stepped one foot into and probably have no friends in. That's what I call being a moral coward
P.S
And the internet activism award goes tooo(drum roll) Matty and Dopplerd!
[ report this ]
P.P.S inshort Matilda, you are complicit by your willfull agressive ignorance. You are not part of the solution, but part of the problem. Hence the Baby Eichmann term coined by Brotha Dr. Churchill stands
[ report this ]
Spook: I know what Churchil meant, and just because I see a bigger meaning in being called Eichmann doesn't mean I am ... well, I've lost track of all the names you have called me as this point. And hell, just for the heck of it, you call me racist. Sweet.
the white working class Nascar/joe six pack crowd that you idolized.
Oh dear. At this point I start to feel really sorry for you, as I am quite sure this is not an act--my first thought--but rather evidence of a small mind. Seriously, you really do not know how far off base you are, do you? Pity, pity.
My god, you have assumptions. Pretty brave, as you don't even know me. You really have no idea what I have done or what communities I've "stepped foot" in. If you knew--and it is not worth explaining to someone who already has 100% of the answers--I am sure your head would explode. But hey, you already know, right? That must make life easy for you--already knowing everyone about everyone who dares to disagree with you.
Spook: People who are wise, or who are striving toward wisdom, know that assumptions are an almost certain sign of a lack of intelligence. Clearly, you do not understand this. I suspect that you impress your fellow fake revolutionaries every now and then over beers, and feel pretty good about yourself, but pal, you are just not as smart and pure as you think you are. I advise you to grow up. You can still fight the man without being unwise. Or, you can just not be taken seriously but anyone but people who already agree with you. How boring and useless is that?
In any case, good luck. You need it.
[ report this ]
SprawlTilda, you do not know me as either. All I have to go by on which to judge the content of your character or lack thereof is by what you type. So when something as tragic and serious as this occurs, and you, Tilda, immediately start spewing Jimboizms, that is immediately reach into an Archie Bunker rubric, how else is a Spook to judge? Oh and I do need luck, but its not the type of luck that you can wish upon me. See are one of the reasons I need luck.
See ya in the funny pages.
[ report this ]
So when something as tragic and serious as this occurs
Exactly. Tragic and serious. Hence, my call for stern punishment of the offender, who clearly does not have any respect for life, as proven by recklessly firing into a bus full of innocents. I fail to see how that makes me morally akin to a Nazi who worked toward genocide, and you've yet to explain your point beyond tossing around a few tired slogans and using terms coined by others. That you can't see how one can be offended by any use of "Eichmann" says much about you, and your understanding of history.
[ report this ]
Jimboizms
It's only 9am, and you've made my day Spook!
[ report this ]
I aim to please ;-)
[ report this ]
Death Penalty is wrong because:
a) It is immoral and cruel to kill people
b) It can not be reversed in case of mistakes
c) It does not reduce crime
c1) in fact it can make criminals more desperate
Discuss amongst yourselves, try using facts.
This was a terrible- I'll go ahead and blame a poor public education system.